The Pixel Watch can’t succeed if Google reuses the same 8-year-old formula

Fossil Gen 5 watch face showing Wear OS logo

Jimmy Westenberg / Android Authority

Rumors about Google’s 1st official foray into smartwatches are picking up steam. What sounded like a myth for lots of many years is now looking additional and more like a certainty, as bits and items of the future Pixel Check out leak from various sources. That has manufactured me imagine: What is the authentic price proposition guiding a Google-built check out? What special attributes would a Pixel Check out present to obstacle the standing quo of Android smartwatches? And to be sincere, I can not arrive up with a very clear solution.

Know it all: The Google Pixel Watch rumor hub

I’m speaking from the perspective of somebody who’s adopted Android’s smartwatch efforts considering that the commence. I’ve owned the initially LG G Watch then the G Check out R, the Huawei View Typical, Skagen Falster, Misfit Vapor X, and now the Galaxy View 4. For various many years, I applied to dress in my watches every day, religiously. Now? Even while Samsung’s hottest is the finest smartwatch I’ve owned, I can fail to remember about it for times, nay months. It sits on my charger right until I try to remember that it exists, so I decide on it up, have on it for a working day or two, and try to pretend that it is well worth the several hundreds of pounds that I compensated for it.

I just discover it a lot more effective to achieve for my cellular phone with its big display screen, good keyboard, and comprehensive app functionality. Plus, I wear a more compact Fitbit Encourage 2 all working day and night to observe my action and snooze. It lasts about a 7 days on a charge.

Wear OS is fundamentally the very same it has been because 2014.

My challenge is not with Samsung or the Galaxy Observe 4 itself, it is the complete merchandise proposition. Android-centered watches have existed for more than 8 decades but the merchandise group has found minimal in phrases of development or enhancement in that timeframe. Sure, we’ve long gone from electric power-hungry 28nm cellular phone processors to more successful wearable-precise 4nm and 5nm processors, we have reduced bezels, enhanced show clarity, dropped the flat tire, and extra a couple of tiles and problems, but Wear OS is basically the same it has normally been.

It is mildly superior at notifications, it does some minimal health and fitness tracking but fails to integrate that into a wider well being-centric ecosystem, and it is a next-amount citizen for most 3rd-occasion apps (Apple Check out guidance comes 1st for a lot of builders). Even Google Assistant has been a gradual, buggy, unresponsive mess on it. Most smartwatches functioning on the platform are trend statements initially and helpful equipment 2nd. Put on OS just exists now, as it has existed for eight decades.

I know which is a bit harsh to say, but is not it the truth?

A Fossil Gen 6 is perched on a picnic table.

Eric Zeman / Android Authority

Even on the components facet, the variety that first built the ecosystem particular has all but disappeared now. LG, Motorola, Sony, Asus, and quite a few other manufacturers have deserted the wearable classification, leaving Fossil — and its many subbrands — and Samsung as the main gamers in town. With Fossil, we get a person hardware blueprint each and every pair of several years (one particular processor, a person RAM configuration, one display screen) that receives rehashed less than different names and shapes ad-infinitum. All watches have a spherical display that appears superior when not in use, but is ineffective for displaying far more than two or three strains of textual content. All of them barely final a day on a charge. All of them have the exact same controls and responsiveness difficulties.

Samsung’s partnership with Google brought a breath of refreshing air to Dress in OS 3.. Extra sensors and measurements, a better health ecosystem, a rotating bezel for controls, and a a lot more powerful phone companion application. It shook the standing quo, and it obviously struck a chord, even nevertheless it pushed Samsung’s ecosystem additional than Google’s.

Our verdict: Samsung Galaxy View 4 evaluation

Google’s Pixel View won’t contend with the hundreds of fashion-branded Fossil watches, but with the Galaxy Watch 4. Which is previously a higher bar to very clear. And even over and above that, Google needs a exceptional providing place to differentiate alone from its competitor. That’s where I’m drawing a blank.

Google Pixel Watch Prosser marketing image showing watch face and strap

Entrance Page Tech / YouTube

The Pixel Check out will retain the identical spherical, inefficient display screen layout, and even nevertheless I just cannot argue with the sleekness of the type issue, I’d at minimum like to see Google give a rectangular solution with far more monitor estate. It is possible to have a one particular-day battery lifetime, so requiring day-to-day charging and interfering with continuous action/sleep monitoring. Fitbit integration seems to be a independent application, and it’s not very clear if we’ll have passive Fitbit monitoring in the history or whether the two Google In shape and Fitbit will coexist.

So what would be the value proposition of this Pixel Observe? What makes it a one of a kind smartwatch among its competitors? What differentiates it from health trackers that can exhibit notifications or anything like the Fitbit Versa 3? Superior but, what tends to make it an indispensable accessory to my telephone? So much, no leak or rumor has answered that problem. It’s just a further Use OS view, but it has the Pixel model.

So what’s the benefit proposition of this Pixel Check out? Nicely… 🤷‍♀️

I’d adore to see Google prove me incorrect when it last but not least announces the Pixel Look at. I’d like to be stunned by new options and unique performance that break away from this eight-12 months limbo of Put on OS. But I’m pretty skeptical.

The “Pixel” brand has grow to be synonymous with excellence in photography and AI in the smartphone sector. We’ll have to hold out to see what that brand name implies in the wearable phase, if anything.

Do you believe the Pixel Check out is adequate to revive Wear OS?

281 votes